For the mentor teacher certificate program I am participating in this semester, I had to observe a foreign teacher and a Chinese teacher for a total of five observations. I observed the foreign teacher twice earlier in the semester, and I just completed the third observation of the Chinese teacher today.
The teachers have to have no more than five years teaching experience and that made it rather hard to find a national teacher here at our school. The "newest" teacher I could find had been teaching seven years. That sent me to the other side of the city (an hour long bus ride away) to a college where I have some guanxi (relationship and connections).
I observed the teacher three times in the past two weeks. That was a lot of traveling back and forth toting Joel each time and Olivia one of the three times. Thankfully, the foreign teachers there graciously watched them while I observed the teacher. It was such a blessing - both the observation and the baby-sitting.
As I watched her teach, I was struck by how much we all benefit from watching each other teach. When I first came to China, I think I thought the Chinese teachers would gain so much insight into Western methodology and teaching styles by observing foreign teachers. The more time I spend in the Chinese teachers' classrooms however, the more I realize that it isn't so much about
them learning anything from
us. It is about teaching, period. We all have strengths and weaknesses. Some of those strengths stem from our past experiences as students and as teachers. We naturally gravitate toward certain tendencies.
To put this in plain terms, let me give an example that I have noticed from my time observing both foreign (non-Chinese) and national (Chinese) teachers over the years. The foreign teachers have a tendency to be very group and pair work oriented. They spend a lot of time having the students talk to each other and to the teacher as well. This could be classified as a strength. They tend to shy away from error correction and teaching grammar. This might be viewed as a weakness. The national teachers however, seem to have a natural approach to correcting the students and teaching grammar in a way that doesn't bring the lesson to a screeching halt. This, generally, is seen as a strength. They have a tendency to lecture and call on students one by one or have the whole class answer, thus limiting the amount of time students talk in class. This can be seen as a weakness.
This example does not account for every foreign and national teacher, but my point is that these teachers have these
tendencies in their teaching. If that is true, it seems reasonable that if they spent time talking about their teaching or at least observing each others' classes that everyone would benefit. This seems to have less to do with "Western" or "Asian" teaching methods and more to do with general areas of strength and growth, don't you think?
So, why is it so hard for us to get into each others' classrooms? What is the big scare or deterrent? I'm not sure. Perhaps it is a lack of understanding or past experiences that have lead both sides to see each other as "sides" rather than see each other as partners in the same game. This is one reason why I enjoy this program so much. It allows me to get involved with both groups and help bridge the gap in a small way.
Next semester I get to form a teacher support group that includes both foreign and national teachers. I am extremely excited about this and cannot wait to see who will be involved and how much they grow as teachers through the process.
Thanks for reading.
See ya' tomorrow! 明天见!